Legal Advisor Warns Sunak: Challenges in Rwanda Flights Bill
Legal Advisor Warns Sunak: C...
Subscribe to Newsletter

Legal Advisor Warns Sunak: Challenges in Rwanda Flights Bill

30 December 2023
2 min.
Legal Advisor Warns Sunak: Challenges in Rwanda Flights Bill

Showdown in Parliament

Constitutional expert David Pannick has raised warnings to the Rishi Sunak government about potential challenges to deportation flights to Rwanda. Specifically, he expressed concerns about appeal claims within the legislation he helped shape.

Concerns Raised by Lord Pannick

According to a source familiar with the discussions, Lord Pannick acknowledged that not addressing individual claims could severely impede the success of the deportation scheme. Government lawyers have cautioned that there is, at best, a 50% chance of initiating the first Rwanda flights before the general election.

Clause IV Controversy

Right-wing Tory MPs are expressing dissatisfaction with Clause IV in the bill, permitting asylum seekers to challenge deportations. Some are advocating for "notwithstanding clauses" to bypass the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). While the bill allows ministers to bypass the Human Rights Act, it stops short of overriding the ECHR. Tory MPs, including the European Research Group (ERG), may oppose the bill without amendments in the new year.

Internal Disagreements

Attorney General Victoria Prentis has reportedly opposed notwithstanding clauses to further disapply human rights law. Former immigration minister Robert Jenrick, who resigned over the perceived weakness of the bill, urged the Home Office to "take back control." Tory moderates in the "One Nation" group are considering amendments to soften the bill's impact.

Moderate Sir Robert Buckland is exploring potential tweaks to ensure compliance with human rights law. However, Damian Green, the One Nation wing's chairman, expressed hope that the third reading would proceed smoothly as long as Sunak adheres to the current, narrow approach.

Challenges and Opposition

Despite winning a first reading vote before Christmas, Sunak faces challenges from both right-wing Tories and One Nation moderates. Only a rebellion of 28 Tory MPs at the crucial third reading stage could undermine his majority.

New legislation permits migrants facing deportation to appeal if they present "compelling" evidence of imminent harm in Rwanda. Home Office predicts a high failure rate (99.5%) for asylum seekers' legal challenges. Critics, especially from the Tory party, consider the assessment outdated, questioning Sunak's assertion that legal challenges will be rare.

Persons6 and Companies3 in the news

British politician
1 place
British politician
2 place
Attorney General for England and Wales
3 place
British barrister
4 place
Secretary of State for Housing
5 place
Chancellor of the Exchequer
6 place
Home Office
2 place
Source foto:
Rating companies


News -this is the latest and most up-to-date information about the resonant events that have occurred in the region. The task of the resource's news feed is to convey to readers information about important events in business, politics, economics, healthcare, culture and other spheres of life in England with maximum accuracy and objectivity.
News - this is coverage of the economic processes taking place in England, the latest news of public life, incidents and an overview of political events. English news is information about the activities of small and medium-sized businesses, the work of housing and communal services, the implementation of significant projects. The site's journalists describe not only the life of the region, but also talk about the current state of the English economy. Everything you need to know about innovations in the field of industry and agriculture, economy and government is collected in the "News" section on
News of England promptly informs the reader, shows the real picture and opens up topical topics. Communication with government structures and business gives us the opportunity to provide our readers with reliable, information-rich material.
The main page of the portal contains the key news of England!
Alena Potapova

Development Director
Died this year
Born this year